Morison Banned Senior Moderator Location: Calgary, AB Join Date: 03/27/2009 Age: Ancient Posts: 1,798 Rally Car: (ex)86 RX-7(built), (ex)2.5RS (bought) |
http://i683.photobucket.com/albums/vv198/aaa-111/PikesPeak/Pikes_Peak_2012/foley/EVOFRONT.jpg
Wow. First Rally: 2001 Driver (7), Co-Driver (44) Drivers (16) Clerk (10), Official (7), Volunteer (4) Cars Built (1), Engines Built (0) Cages Built (0) Last Updated, January 4, 2015 ![]()
|
john vanlandingham John Vanlandingham Super Moderator Location: Ford Asylum, Sleezattle, WA Join Date: 12/20/2005 Age: Fossilized Posts: 14,152 Rally Car: Saab 96 V4 |
Hey Jason those are great photos.. they show very well just how utterly lacking in very very basic understanding the "i'm an injur-near---so i noez
about cages' guy is. His blabbering about the oi line leak is appalling. John Vanlandingham Sleezattle, WA, USA Vive le Prole-le-ralliat www.rallyrace.net/jvab CALL +1 206 431-9696 Remember! Pacific Standard Time is 3 hours behind Eastern Standard Time. |
john vanlandingham John Vanlandingham Super Moderator Location: Ford Asylum, Sleezattle, WA Join Date: 12/20/2005 Age: Fossilized Posts: 14,152 Rally Car: Saab 96 V4 |
And double wow. ![]() John Vanlandingham Sleezattle, WA, USA Vive le Prole-le-ralliat www.rallyrace.net/jvab CALL +1 206 431-9696 Remember! Pacific Standard Time is 3 hours behind Eastern Standard Time. |
mekilljoydammit Senior Moderator Join Date: 09/22/2010 Age: Midlife Crisis Posts: 336 Rally Car: No rally car yet |
Goddamn. Speaking as an actual injurneer, that pretty much backs up my thinking to use the FIA rally style cages as a basis in anything future that I build; I mean goddamn, how can anyone look at the way that deformed and conclude the cage was done right for its application?
|
heymagic Banned Super Moderator Location: La la land Join Date: 01/25/2006 Age: Fossilized Posts: 3,740 Rally Car: Not a Volvo |
That cage is a current NRS design, except for the A pillar supports. Anders believes it is adequate...I don't and refuse to log book such a cage.
But...it does have a diagonal on the passenger side, it terminates in the backstays. The cage did deform, front twisted to the drivers side, rear to the passengers side. Cage did not break, welds held. Builder did his job. Most importantly the occupants are ok so believe it or not the cage did its job and was adequate. Cages are not built to never deform. No way can you build a structure in a car with occupants that won't give. Even at relatively slow impacts a decent hit can total a car, such as Sean's Merkur. FIA cages, great seats, good helmets, HNRs...all a clculated risk not a guarantee. Drive wisely. |
FunctionAuto Tyler Patik Infallible Moderator Location: Casper, Wy Join Date: 12/13/2009 Age: Midlife Crisis Posts: 131 Rally Car: 1995 IMpreza |
I am assuming an "x" in the main hoop would have made quite a difference as far as the co- driver was concerned. Those door bars look terrible because as mentioned you aren't racing at the same time as other cars, but even to that extent with the "s" bend in there how much would that actually help?
What else would everyone change? And there has to be at least something this builder got right, right? I am just intrigued as to the tech side of this because both of my cages have been built for me, and I would like to better understand the reason bars go here and gussets go here, etc. For reference this crash seemed similar but not as bad as jari Matti's Portugal crash and they walked away from that with less injuries and a far more intact car. Jari matti Portugal crash |
zerodegreec Oh look, waffles.... Professional Moderator Location: Earth Join Date: 03/06/2012 Posts: 103 Rally Car: see you on the stages |
Well I have to agree that the cage is not acceptable especially for a 2 seater. One thing that I have taken from these photos is a better understanding of what to look for in a "safe ride" as a co-driver.
The builder and or the person that bolted the Navi seat into the car (to allow a second person to be in the car) should be charged. Intercom and electronics dude. www.zerodegreec.ca |
john vanlandingham John Vanlandingham Super Moderator Location: Ford Asylum, Sleezattle, WA Join Date: 12/20/2005 Age: Fossilized Posts: 14,152 Rally Car: Saab 96 V4 |
Yeah yeah whatever. The major stupidity of the idiot braggart is in thinking. Not recognizing his own extreme limitations and ignoring precedent. Human errors, and those human errors explain partially by his age, location (cultur of the area) and what passes for but isn't "education". Anybody who ignores the use of the bodyshell as a relatively strong foundation on which they ADD an additional reinforcing structure--the cage--who ignores that the base structure---the bodyshell has some somee basic "coherence" and strength is a fool. Anybody who destroys the basic shell and as we see from the naked cage, the rest of the "car' kinda disappeared so it must have not been intergrated together with the cage at all---any normal person doing that is just foolish, a twerp bragging that he "knows cages" its outrageous. Yeah the lives were saved. But that was to a large degree pure dumb luck and not "thankls' to the cage. It was that they just missed the bigger rocks and the way a object skipping down hill has glancing blows as a function of the steepness of the hill. draw a piccie if that ain't clear, (My body has been the object skipping down hills, duddn't hurt near as much going down as smashing you body into an uphill face..You kinda notice that when its direct blows into your own "bodyshell" ![]() had that thing flipped on level ground and say slid wide an hit a rock face on the outside of the car and had a full sudden stop it would have been 2 guys dead thanks to the arrogance of whatever the genius guy bragging is called. John Vanlandingham Sleezattle, WA, USA Vive le Prole-le-ralliat www.rallyrace.net/jvab CALL +1 206 431-9696 Remember! Pacific Standard Time is 3 hours behind Eastern Standard Time. |
john vanlandingham John Vanlandingham Super Moderator Location: Ford Asylum, Sleezattle, WA Join Date: 12/20/2005 Age: Fossilized Posts: 14,152 Rally Car: Saab 96 V4 |
Glad you said it, and not me. But...charged with what? It's not against the law to be a total idjit. John Vanlandingham Sleezattle, WA, USA Vive le Prole-le-ralliat www.rallyrace.net/jvab CALL +1 206 431-9696 Remember! Pacific Standard Time is 3 hours behind Eastern Standard Time. |
heymagic Banned Super Moderator Location: La la land Join Date: 01/25/2006 Age: Fossilized Posts: 3,740 Rally Car: Not a Volvo |
We can't control bragging. A rally compliant FIA derived cage may well not have survived any better.
I agree on the body panels flying off and both of us certainly would have built the car differently. I mentioned earlier it wa shit house luck and I still feel that, but people need to realize cages bend and some hits bend them a lot. I won't log book those cages for NRS so I'm not a proponent of them and am not defending the design, just want people to realize what can happen with any cage. |
zerodegreec Oh look, waffles.... Professional Moderator Location: Earth Join Date: 03/06/2012 Posts: 103 Rally Car: see you on the stages |
Well if he is infact an engineer. He can be charged with criminal negligence to start with.
This to me shows that the design of the cage was for a single occupant. The fact that two seats were fitted to the car shows criminal negligence. Intercom and electronics dude. www.zerodegreec.ca Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 08/15/2012 11:05PM by zerodegreec. |
Morison Banned Senior Moderator Location: Calgary, AB Join Date: 03/27/2009 Age: Ancient Posts: 1,798 Rally Car: (ex)86 RX-7(built), (ex)2.5RS (bought) |
Every time I see the door bars I can't help but think about how they would have failed in a serious side impact. (Straight into the seat where the bends are)
I suspect A-pillar bars would have helped in this one as well. I don't think I'd get in a car with that cage. First Rally: 2001 Driver (7), Co-Driver (44) Drivers (16) Clerk (10), Official (7), Volunteer (4) Cars Built (1), Engines Built (0) Cages Built (0) Last Updated, January 4, 2015 ![]()
|
Morison Banned Senior Moderator Location: Calgary, AB Join Date: 03/27/2009 Age: Ancient Posts: 1,798 Rally Car: (ex)86 RX-7(built), (ex)2.5RS (bought) |
I think we all know that cages are expected to bend in a big enough impact. What concerns me is that other than the initial impact, these were not 'hard' impacts but, as John says, glancing blows. If they had gone into the trees it would be a different story.
First Rally: 2001 Driver (7), Co-Driver (44) Drivers (16) Clerk (10), Official (7), Volunteer (4) Cars Built (1), Engines Built (0) Cages Built (0) Last Updated, January 4, 2015 ![]()
|
modernbeat Jason McDaniel Mod Moderator Location: Dallas, TX Join Date: 12/14/2007 Age: Possibly Wise Posts: 401 Rally Car: 1963 SAAB Historic, 1995 Impreza Open Light totaled at WRC Mexico, 2005 STi Pikes Peak winner |
|
FunctionAuto Tyler Patik Infallible Moderator Location: Casper, Wy Join Date: 12/13/2009 Age: Midlife Crisis Posts: 131 Rally Car: 1995 IMpreza |
|